If you run a site or write a spec, you’ll see the same three families of sealant come up again and again: polyurethane, polysulphide and silicone. They all come out of a gun and they all fill a joint, so it’s tempting to treat them as interchangeable. They aren’t. Pick the wrong one and a joint that should last for years can start failing within a season or two.
We’re Pioneer Sealants Ltd, Bedford-based specialist sealant applicators with over 20 years in construction behind the company. We use polyurethane, polysulphide and silicone sealants on commercial, industrial and residential jobs across Bedfordshire, London, the Midlands and the East of England. Here’s a plain, practical guide to polyurethane vs polysulphide sealant, and where silicone fits in.
The short answer
- Polyurethane is the everyday workhorse for external building joints: movement joints in brick and block, precast panels, cladding and many concrete joints. It grips well, copes with movement and is often paintable.
- Polysulphide is the one you reach for when the joint has to put up with something harsher: chemicals, fuel, oil, or constant contact with water.
- Silicone comes into its own on glazing, curtain walling and anywhere UV and weathering are the main enemy, and inside for sanitary work. Paint won’t stick to it.
That’s the rule of thumb. The real answer always comes from the specification and the manufacturer’s data sheet for the exact product.
Polyurethane sealant: where it works best
Polyurethane (often shortened to PU) is probably the sealant we apply most on commercial building joints. Low-modulus PU sealants are soft and stretchy, which is exactly what you want in a joint that opens and closes with temperature changes.
Typical uses:
- Movement joints in brickwork and blockwork.
- Joints between precast concrete panels and around stair cores.
- Metal and composite cladding joints.
- Perimeter seals around frames where the sealant will be painted or needs to match a masonry colour.
Things to watch: many PU sealants need a primer on porous or awkward surfaces, they don’t like being applied to damp joints, and some grades can discolour or chalk with long UV exposure. Check the data sheet for the substrate and exposure you’ve got.

Polysulphide sealant: where it earns its keep
Polysulphide has been around for a long time and is still the go-to on many civil and industrial jobs. It’s usually supplied as a two-part material that’s mixed on site, though one-part versions exist. Its big strengths are resistance to chemicals, fuels and oils, and its ability to stay sealed in joints that are wet a lot of the time.
Typical uses:
- Concrete joints that see fuel, oil or chemical spills, such as service yards, loading bays, forecourts and plant areas.
- Water-retaining and drainage structures, where the joint is under water or regularly soaked.
- Expansion joints in concrete where the spec calls for a tough, chemically resistant seal.
Things to watch: two-part polysulphide has a working time once mixed, so you mix what you can use, not the whole tin. It takes longer to cure than many one-part sealants, and it still needs clean, dry, sound joint faces and the right primer. It’s also generally stiffer than a low-modulus PU, so it isn’t always the best pick for a facade joint with lots of movement.
And where does silicone fit?
Silicone isn’t the loser in this comparison, it’s just built for different jobs. High-quality silicones handle sunlight and weather extremely well, so they’re the usual choice for curtain walling, structural glazing and window perimeters where appearance matters for years. Inside, sanitary silicone with mould resistance is what goes round baths, showers and sinks.
The catch: you can’t paint silicone, and once it’s been in a joint, its residue can stop other sealants bonding. If you’re replacing old silicone with a polyurethane or polysulphide, the joint faces have to be properly cleaned back first. We covered the material basics in our post on mastic vs silicone vs caulk.

How to choose: five questions we ask on site
- What’s the joint moving? A facade joint that opens and closes daily needs a low-modulus sealant with the right movement capability. A static joint is more forgiving.
- What will it be exposed to? Fuel, oil, cleaning chemicals or standing water point towards polysulphide. Strong sun on glazing points towards silicone.
- What’s the substrate? Concrete, brick, aluminium, powder-coated steel and stone all behave differently. Primers and compatibility matter.
- Does it need painting or colour matching? PU is often paintable and comes in plenty of colours. Silicone isn’t paintable.
- What’s the spec? On commercial jobs, the specification and the manufacturer’s guidance come first. If something on site doesn’t suit the specified product, we raise it before we start, not after.
Whatever the material, the basics don’t change: the right joint depth, a backing rod or bond breaker so the sealant only sticks to the two sides, clean faces, primer where needed, and a properly tooled finish.
How we can help
We apply polyurethane, polysulphide and silicone sealants and use products from manufacturers including Sika, Arbo, Tremco CPG and Dow. On concrete work that ranges from car park and precast wall joints to warehouse floors. See our expansion joint sealing, concrete joint sealing and facade and curtain wall sealant pages for more on each. We’re Constructionline Silver members, and RAMS are available on request.
FAQ
Is polysulphide better than polyurethane?
Not better, just different. Polysulphide wins on chemical, fuel and water resistance. Low-modulus polyurethane is usually the better choice for building joints with a lot of movement.
Can I put polyurethane over old polysulphide or silicone?
Not straight over it. The old sealant needs cutting out and the joint faces cleaning back, then primed if the data sheet says so. Always check compatibility with the manufacturer.
Is polysulphide sealant still used?
Yes. It’s still widely specified for concrete joints in industrial and civil work, especially where fuel, oil or water are involved.
Can you paint polyurethane sealant?
Many PU sealants can be painted once cured, but check the product data sheet. Silicone can’t be painted.
Get a price for your joints
Got a spec to price, or joints on site you’re not sure about? Send us drawings or a few photos and we’ll tell you what we’d use and why. Call 01234 607 252, WhatsApp 07757 772 880, or use our contact page. Every job is priced, planned and managed by Pioneer Sealants from start to finish.
Mastic and sealant work in London: we cover every London borough. See Mastic Man London or go straight to your area: North London · North-East London · East London · South-East London · South-West London · West London · Westminster & the City.
Insured & pre-qualified
For homeowners, builders and main contractors.
- £10m Employer’s LiabilityInsurance cover
- £5m Public Liability & Professional IndemnityInsurance cover
- Constructionline Silver member

- NVQ Level 2Sealant Applicator
Over 20 years in construction
Products we use
Sealants and adhesives we use on site.
Brand names and logos are trademarks of their respective owners and are shown to identify products we use. No endorsement is implied.
Got a joint that needs doing properly?
Call us, or send a few photos on WhatsApp for the quickest quote.
- Opening hours
- Monday – Friday8:00am – 6:30pm
- Saturday9:00am – 4:00pm
- SundayClosed
















